clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Weekly comments and recs report: February 16-22

We have a new weekly comments leader! Someone check to make sure Jakubazookas is OK.

By Stacey
Patrick McDermott

Some new stuff in today's report. First, we have this handy summary report at the top. In the total comments section, I cut out anyone who had three or less comments because the list was just too long and unwieldy. So if you see your name just below but it's not on the comments ranking, it's because you had 1-3 comments. This accounts for 76 of the 163 posters.

I waited until a little later than usual to run the report since people are still commenting on yesterday's posts, but I had to make the cutoff somewhere. Without further ado...

Roll Call Info, February 16-22
Total comments 3,461
Total commenters 163
Total posts 27
Commenter list ARSkinsFan, Andrew Morris, Andrew T. Fisher, AndrewTorrez, Andrew_G, Andrew_Lew, Astronaut Mike Dexter, Auricursine, BCinVA, Brady Anders, Bridgemaniac, Broktun, Brugalex, CM8, CStoneNo37, Cal4Commish, Chanumas, Charles Barrus, Commanche, D. Reese, Darren89, DaveAA, DeadheadSkins, Dedekind, Eat More Esskay, Emperor Lrrr, Fahrenheit 451, FreddieBoomBoomBynum, Gamecock24, Go To War Miss Agnes, Gregory O, IUterpfan, InfrasonicTom, J(O's)elskIL, Jakattak88, Jake Nazar, Jakubazookas, James F, Joe Davola, Jokes & Burns, Kevin Ebert, Knubles and Bits, LarryMcVA, MDJHawk, MWooster, MarylandPride410, McNulty'sBirds, Michimore Wizskins, Montay23, Mr MaLoR, MudDawg, NSOsFan, NYScott, Nafer, NattyBoAndOldBay, NickMarkaces, NittanyBlueHen, O'Kay, O'sFan21, O'sFan_, OEutaw, Orangerunner, OrioleGuru, OriolesRule13, OsNBohs, OsandBucs, Osinnyc, PBR me ASAP!, PSUbaltimore, PTcello, Parkinglotninja, PatrioticMerkin, PhilR8, Philly O's, PonsonPwn, Quisenberry4Ever, RED SOX are #1 in my heart, Rayvenator, Russellgood2573, Ryan Herich, RyanWarmly, Schecty, ScootMcgoot, SibiGnana, Slobbity, Southern Marylander, Stacey, Steve., Strat12, Tarbox, Tunaflipper, WestcoastO'sFan, Wieters Wieners, Wiz fan rocks, Xari0tis, Y Not, YeahDonnie, Zeke McGeek, aaronroyer, ahoque24, alexw, attgig, bcartermn, betterthanburke, birdman, bmorenoice, booth not boo, brek, buffamore, chitomartinez, chooch.wilbury, claudecat, danistheguy, daveh873, dfa, dippinkind, doktorpeace, droford, duck, edcoffin, essenpee, fat_daddyo, fishoutawata, freight69, gio2chat, hnmnf, honeybear, hookstrapped, illyinphilly, j.q. higgins, jim66, jobe, kba26, kdbterps, keyshonn, leo4725, lupin, nattybroh, neveraging, nmcvicker03, nutter202, pabirdfan, perpetualstudent, punkrawka, risuena, rlc, rocs522292, rogerramjet, schneerson666, selftitled85, seriapatrate, sluggo 2.0, tflach2, the madman of birdland, theotter89, thewaywardO, thezeroes, tim.byer, timg56, tjk, wbecke01, zknower, zsiv

Total Comments (>3)

Looks birdman has finally adjusted to east coast commenting. But what happened to Jakubazookas?

# Commenter # Comments
1 birdman 275
2 O'sFan21 178
3 PBR me ASAP! 169
4 Jakubazookas 150
5 Andrew_Lew 145
6 Eat More Esskay 136
7 Joe Davola 112
8 Stacey 111
9 duck 105
10 punkrawka 100
11 Wieters Wieners 97
12 kba26 93
13 James F 93
14 daveh873 92
15 NSOsFan 91
16 Astronaut Mike Dexter 91
17 j.q. higgins 84
18 WestcoastO'sFan 67
19 CStoneNo37 60
20 Strat12 54
21 sluggo 2.0 51
22 J(O's)elskIL 49
23 PhilR8 48
24 keyshonn 41
25 DaveAA 41
26 Tunaflipper 36
27 brek 31
28 Jokes & Burns 30
29 hnmnf 29
30 Emperor Lrrr 28
31 dfa 28
32 tflach2 28
33 Quisenberry4Ever 27
34 PonsonPwn 27
35 risuena 27
36 YeahDonnie 25
37 CM8 24
38 Broktun 22
39 tjk 21
40 Philly O's 20
41 zknower 20
42 Gamecock24 20
43 wbecke01 19
44 pabirdfan 17
45 Jake Nazar 17
46 nattybroh 16
47 Zeke McGeek 13
48 Darren89 12
49 freight69 12
50 Andrew_G 12
51 lupin 11
52 perpetualstudent 11
53 schneerson666 11
54 jobe 11
55 selftitled85 10
56 fishoutawata 10
57 the madman of birdland 10
58 essenpee 9
59 ScootMcgoot 9
60 PatrioticMerkin 8
61 hookstrapped 8
62 OEutaw 7
63 Xari0tis 7
64 FreddieBoomBoomBynum 7
65 Osinnyc 7
66 Charles Barrus 7
67 fat_daddyo 7
68 aaronroyer 6
69 Southern Marylander 6
70 Commanche 6
71 O'Kay 6
72 dippinkind 6
73 Cal4Commish 6
74 PTcello 5
75 Andrew T. Fisher 5
76 bmorenoice 5
77 Michimore Wizskins 5
78 Y Not 5
79 NittanyBlueHen 5
80 OrioleGuru 4
81 ARSkinsFan 4
82 thezeroes 4
83 Russellgood2573 4
84 OsNBohs 4
85 Orangerunner 4
86 D. Reese 4
87 gio2chat 4

Total Recs

Wow, that Stacey chick is a rec machine! And how about James, the self-proclaimed rec hater, coming in third? I guess people identify with his vitriol.

# Commenter # Recs
1 Stacey 77
2 Southern Marylander 60
3 James F 48
4 PBR me ASAP! 48
5 aaronroyer 37
6 Wieters Wieners 32
7 Eat More Esskay 30
8 birdman 26
9 CStoneNo37 24
10 DaveAA 22
11 Andrew_Lew 21
12 J(O's)elskIL 21
13 kba26 20
14 NSOsFan 20
15 daveh873 19
16 Jakubazookas 19
17 zknower 14
18 punkrawka 13
19 O'sFan21 12
20 Philly O's 12
21 Osinnyc 11
22 Quisenberry4Ever 9
23 j.q. higgins 8
24 brek 7
25 hookstrapped 7
26 risuena 7
27 hnmnf 6
28 Joe Davola 6
29 nattybroh 6
30 the madman of birdland 6
31 duck 5
32 Strat12 5
33 Astronaut Mike Dexter 4
34 bcartermn 4
35 sluggo 2.0 4
36 tflach2 4
37 WestcoastO'sFan 4
38 Zeke McGeek 4
39 Montay23 3
40 tjk 3
41 Tunaflipper 3
42 jobe 3
43 fishoutawata 2
44 Jake Nazar 2
45 jAndrew_G 2
46 Jokes & Burns 2
47 Knubles and Bits 2
48 leo4725 2
49 Michimore Wizskins 2
50 OsNBohs 2
51 PhilR8 2
52 schneerson666 2
53 wbecke01 2
54 CM8 1
55 Commanche 1
56 dfa 1
57 Emperor Lrrr 1
58 essenpee 1
59 gio2chat 1
60 Nafer 1
61 nutter202 1
62 PatrioticMerkin 1
63 PonsonPwn 1
64 PTcello 1
65 RED SOX are #1 in my heart 1
66 Schecty 1
67 thewaywardO 1
68 YeahDonnie 1

Recs Per Comment

zk gets the award this week for highest rec ratio with double digit comments.

# Commenter # Recs # Comments Rec/Comment Ratio
1 Southern Marylander 60 6 10.00
2 aaronroyer 37 6 6.17
3 bcartermn 4 1 4.00
4 leo4725 2 1 2.00
5 Osinnyc 11 7 1.57
6 Knubles and Bits 2 2 1.00
7 Montay23 3 3 1.00
8 RED SOX are #1 in my heart 1 1 1.00
9 hookstrapped 7 8 0.88
10 zknower 14 20 0.70
11 Stacey 77 111 0.69
12 Philly O's 12 20 0.60
13 the madman of birdland 6 10 0.60
14 DaveAA 22 41 0.54
15 James F 48 93 0.52
16 nutter202 1 2 0.50
17 OsNBohs 2 4 0.50
18 Schecty 1 2 0.50
19 J(O's)elskIL 21 49 0.43
20 CStoneNo37 24 60 0.40
21 Michimore Wizskins 2 5 0.40
22 nattybroh 6 16 0.38
23 Nafer 1 3 0.33
24 Quisenberry4Ever 9 27 0.33
25 thewaywardO 1 3 0.33
26 Wieters Wieners 32 97 0.33
27 Zeke McGeek 4 13 0.31
28 PBR me ASAP! 48 169 0.28
29 jobe 3 11 0.27
30 risuena 7 27 0.26
31 gio2chat 1 4 0.25
32 brek 7 31 0.23
33 Eat More Esskay 30 136 0.22
34 NSOsFan 20 91 0.22
35 kba26 20 93 0.22
36 hnmnf 6 29 0.21
37 daveh873 19 92 0.21
38 fishoutawata 2 10 0.20
39 PTcello 1 5 0.20
40 schneerson666 2 11 0.18
41 Andrew_G 2 12 0.17
42 Commanche 1 6 0.17
43 Jake Nazar 2 13 0.15
44 Andrew_Lew 21 144 0.15
45 tflach2 4 28 0.14
46 tjk 3 21 0.14
47 punkrawka 13 100 0.13
48 Jakubazookas 19 150 0.13
49 PatrioticMerkin 1 8 0.13
50 essenpee 1 9 0.11
51 wbecke01 2 19 0.11
52 j.q. higgins 8 84 0.10
53 birdman 26 275 0.09
54 Strat12 5 54 0.09
55 Tunaflipper 3 36 0.08
56 sluggo 2.0 4 51 0.08
57 O'sFan21 12 178 0.07
58 Jokes & Burns 2 30 0.07
59 WestcoastO'sFan 4 67 0.06
60 Joe Davola 6 112 0.05
61 duck 5 105 0.05
62 Astronaut Mike Dexter 4 91 0.04
63 CM8 1 24 0.04
64 PhilR8 2 48 0.04
65 YeahDonnie 1 25 0.04
66 PonsonPwn 1 27 0.04
67 dfa 1 28 0.04
68 Emperor Lrrr 1 28 0.04

Year To Date

The complete list for each of the below categories can be found here.

Top 25 Commenters

# Commenter # Comments
1 Jakubazookas 1797
2 O'sFan21 1447
3 duck 1317
4 WestcoastO'sFan 1210
5 kba26 1187
6 Wieters Wieners 1100
7 Eat More Esskay 958
8 birdman 909
9 PBR me ASAP! 899
10 Joe Davola 892
11 j.q. higgins 864
12 punkrawka 860
13 PhilR8 803
14 the madman of birdland 783
15 Astronaut Mike Dexter 772
16 Andrew_Lew 730
17 sluggo 2.0 718
18 PatrioticMerkin 631
19 daveh873 620
20 Broktun 601
21 Stacey 504
22 Tunaflipper 494
23 Strat12 493
24 NSOsFan 477
25 James F 428

Most Recs - Top 25

# Commenter # Recs
1 Wieters Wieners 267
2 Southern Marylander 238
3 Jakubazookas 234
4 Stacey 214
5 Eat More Esskay 181
6 PBR me ASAP! 172
7 daveh873 163
8 kba26 148
9 O'sFan21 128
10 j.q. higgins 123
11 duck 119
12 PonsonPwn 116
13 NSOsFan 112
14 Joe Davola 108
15 punkrawka 93
16 Andrew_Lew 90
17 tflach2 86
18 the madman of birdland 85
19 James F 77
20 Astronaut Mike Dexter 74
21 JeCaThRe 74
22 CStoneNo37 73
23 Quisenberry4Ever 73
24 WestcoastO'sFan 73
25 DaveAA 72

Top 25 Recs Per Comment (Min 70 comments)

Remember, the minimum for this is an average of 10 comments per week.

# Commenter # Recs # Comments Recs/Comment Ratio
1 Quisenberry4Ever 73 93 0.78
2 J(O's)elskIL 56 127 0.44
3 Stacey 214 504 0.42
4 Philly O's 29 72 0.40
5 PonsonPwn 116 299 0.39
6 tflach2 86 245 0.35
7 zknower 53 172 0.31
8 daveh873 163 620 0.26
9 wbecke01 20 82 0.24
10 Wieters Wieners 267 1100 0.24
11 NSOsFan 112 477 0.23
12 JeCaThRe 74 318 0.23
13 hnmnf 17 77 0.22
14 DaveAA 72 337 0.21
15 PBR me ASAP! 172 899 0.19
16 Eat More Esskay 181 958 0.19
17 risuena 36 192 0.19
18 Zeke McGeek 30 162 0.19
19 Chanumas 20 111 0.18
20 James F 77 428 0.18
21 CStoneNo37 73 417 0.18
22 Andrew_G 14 84 0.17
23 Emperor Lrrr 20 121 0.17
24 Jakattak88 13 89 0.15
25 j.q. higgins 123 864 0.14
26 brek 36 262 0.14

Most Rec'd Comments

# # Recs Commenter Comment Link
1 31 j.q. higgins nice
2 30 Quisenberry4Ever Off topic: my daughter was born yesterday!!
3 29 Stacey Good news, friends
4 26 Southern Marylander [no title]
5 23 Southern Marylander Thoughts for Spring Training...
6 20 Southern Marylander [no title]
7 20 Southern Marylander [no title]
8 18 Southern Marylander I'm ready to throw down.
9 17 J(O's)elskIL It's not even close. Cal>>>>>Jeter
10 16 PBR me ASAP! [no title]
11 16 punkrawka So kinda like NL baseball?
12 16 Stacey You know what?
13 16 CStoneNo37 Those are both significantly less than the 116 I am projecting.
14 16 tflach2 He didn't comment on Balfour's shoulder,
15 15 Southern Marylander The following post is payment to JeCaThRe for services provided and is in list format (as requested) with Jennifer Lawrence offering dramatic interpretations of my response to JeCaThRe offering said services.
16 15 aaronroyer Making a few offseason House of Cards gifs
17 14 aaronroyer ...
18 14 j.q. higgins [no title]
19 13 J(O's)elskIL I also wake up at 5am nearly every morning, no matter what
20 13 PonsonPwn Because all we need are Orioles gifs
21 13 O'sFan21 losing to the Yankees in the playoffs because of a blown call is a GREAT story
22 13 duck So, apparently, I just accidently deleted my school's entire website
23 13 Quisenberry4Ever thanks to everyone for the well wishes and congrats.
24 12 PonsonPwn These GIFs are cute and all but I miss baseball related ones.
25 12 PBR me ASAP! Well, Chris...
26 12 D.Szymborski [no title]
27 12 J(O's)elskIL Just look at that positioning! No need to worry for who will take over at 3B after Manny retires in 18-20 years.
28 12 Southern Marylander [no title]
29 12 Stacey bye, asshole
30 12 Stacey oh come on
31 12 Southern Marylander Here's to Yoon...

More From Camden Chat