clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Weekly comments and recs report: February 23-March 1

Another week, another recs report

By Stacey
Rob Carr
Roll Call Info, February 23-March 2
Total comments 5,229
Total commenters 167
Commenter list 33, ARSkinsFan, AceJC, Adam J. Morris, Andrew Morris, AndrewTorrez, Andrew_G, Andrew_Lew, Astronaut Mike Dexter, BENNY BIRDMAN, Bill in LA, BirdFanLA, Broktun, CM8, CStoneNo37, CarefreeFC, Chanumas, Charles Barrus, D. Reese, D.Szymborski, DJCahill, Darren89, DaveAA, Earlwasthebest, Eat More Esskay, Emperor Lrrr, Fahrenheit 451, Fallclassic66, Five-by-Five, Gamecock24, Gilesj2, GiveEmTheBird, Gonfoo, Gregory O, Gromm, I3rad, InfrasonicTom, J(O's)elskIL, JT54, Jakattak88, Jake Nazar, Jakubazookas, James F, JeCaThRe, Joe Davola, Jokes & Burns, Knubles and Bits, Mark E., McNulty'sBirds, Michimore Wizskins, Milk Steak, NSOsFan, NickMarkaces, NittanyBlueHen, O'Kay, O'sFan21, O'sFan_, O'sandNatyBo's, OEutaw, Orangerunner, OrioleGuru, OriolesEh, OriolesRule13, OsNBohs, OsandBucs, Osinnyc, PBR me ASAP!, PSUbaltimore, PTcello, PatrioticMerkin, PaulFolk, PhilR8, Philly O's, Pocket Ninja, PonsonPwn, Poseur, Quisenberry4Ever, RED SOX are #1 in my heart, Rayvenator, Rich Hauck, Rugby Run Run, Russellgood2573, Ryan Pollack, Schoolly_D, SibiGnana, Sierra Matt, SinCityO, Skipper_32, Son of Roenickstein, Southern Marylander, Stacey, Strat12, Tunaflipper, Tyler.S., Wes Mantooth?, WestcoastO'sFan, WhyaTerp, Wieters Wieners, Xari0tis, Y Not, YeahDonnie, Zeke McGeek, aaronroyer, alexw, angry_slav, ben.cassell3, birdman, bmorenoice, boog26, booth not boo, brek, chitomartinez, claudecat, curbeamc, daveh873, dead-on-red, dfa, dippinkind, duck, eglooney, fat_daddyo, fishoutawata, fortheglory31, freight69, gavin1177, ghostofErikThompson, gio2chat, greg683x, hnmnf, hookstrapped, j.q. higgins, jburl123, jim66, jobe, kba26, kdbterps, keyshonn, leo4725, lupin, maddi, mbernadette, milkman41, mindpinball, mystery tramp, nattybroh, neveraging, pabirdfan, perpetualstudent, punkrawka, purplenorange, risuena, rlc, rocs522292, selftitled85, sellers.dean, sluggo 2.0, tflach2, the madman of birdland, thewaywardO, timg56, tjk, tony.lescallett, waitforthecall, wbecke01, wickedwitch, zknower, zsiv

Total Comments (>3)

With 26 comments on the week, I think it's time for claudecat to give up his hot lurker status.

# Commenter # Comments
1 O'sFan21 354
2 Jakubazookas 311
3 Wieters Wieners 268
4 fat_daddyo 238
5 Eat More Esskay 237
6 Tunaflipper 218
7 birdman 218
8 punkrawka 201
9 JeCaThRe 192
10 kba26 183
11 sluggo 2.0 131
12 the madman of birdland 123
13 PhilR8 117
14 WestcoastO'sFan 115
15 risuena 113
16 duck 100
17 Andrew_Lew 96
18 j.q. higgins 87
19 NSOsFan 84
20 Broktun 82
21 James F 81
22 PBR me ASAP! 79
23 daveh873 79
24 Strat12 73
25 Astronaut Mike Dexter 72
26 Andrew_G 66
27 Joe Davola 66
28 Stacey 62
29 Quisenberry4Ever 62
30 Southern Marylander 61
31 DaveAA 58
32 Zeke McGeek 49
33 brek 44
34 Emperor Lrrr 43
35 keyshonn 40
36 OsNBohs 37
37 Xari0tis 34
38 Jakattak88 34
39 timg56 33
40 PatrioticMerkin 32
41 PonsonPwn 27
42 dfa 26
43 claudecat 26
44 33 25
45 pabirdfan 24
46 tflach2 22
47 J(O's)elskIL 21
48 lupin 21
49 zsiv 19
50 CStoneNo37 17
51 CM8 16
52 Osinnyc 16
53 Philly O's 15
54 zknower 15
55 Sierra Matt 15
56 Mark E. 14
57 wbecke01 14
58 McNulty'sBirds 13
59 perpetualstudent 13
60 NickMarkaces 12
61 SibiGnana 10
62 BENNY BIRDMAN 10
63 gio2chat 10
64 OsandBucs 8
65 Charles Barrus 8
66 fishoutawata 7
67 PTcello 7
68 Michimore Wizskins 6
69 tjk 6
70 jim66 6
71 alexw 6
72 Darren89 6
73 O'Kay 6
74 aaronroyer 5
75 Jokes & Burns 5
76 hnmnf 5
77 OEutaw 5
78 selftitled85 5
79 Orangerunner 5
80 Knubles and Bits 5
81 PaulFolk 5
82 PSUbaltimore 4
83 neveraging 4
84 Son of Roenickstein 4
85 OrioleGuru 4
86 Fallclassic66 4
87 YeahDonnie 4
88 hookstrapped 4
89 NittanyBlueHen 4

Total Recs

Quite a week for MD'er, who more than doubled the next closest guy. I guess good things happen when you finally start using words!

# Commenter # Recs
1 Southern Marylander 93
2 Jakubazookas 46
3 Eat More Esskay 39
4 Wieters Wieners 36
5 PonsonPwn 31
6 risuena 31
7 daveh873 30
8 PBR me ASAP! 27
9 Quisenberry4Ever 25
10 JeCaThRe 24
11 Pocket Ninja 24
12 James F 18
13 kba26 18
14 O'sFan21 18
15 aaronroyer 17
16 Astronaut Mike Dexter 17
17 WestcoastO'sFan 17
18 punkrawka 14
19 Tunaflipper 14
20 wbecke01 14
21 PhilR8 13
22 NSOsFan 12
23 Philly O's 12
24 Andrew_Lew 11
25 hnmnf 11
26 Stacey 11
27 Strat12 11
28 SibiGnana 10
29 Joe Davola 9
30 Jokes & Burns 9
31 NickMarkaces 9
32 the madman of birdland 9
33 birdman 8
34 brek 8
35 D.Szymborski 8
36 gio2chat 8
37 fat_daddyo 7
38 j.q. higgins 7
39 zknower 7
40 DaveAA 6
41 duck 5
42 Osinnyc 5
43 Xari0tis 5
44 Broktun 4
45 Mark E. 4
46 McNulty'sBirds 4
47 pabirdfan 4
48 Darren89 3
49 dfa 3
50 Emperor Lrrr 3
51 Jakattak88 3
52 Jake Nazar 3
53 PTcello 3
54 sluggo 2.0 3
55 tflach2 3
56 Zeke McGeek 3
57 Andrew_G 2
58 CStoneNo37 2
59 eglooney 2
60 keyshonn 2
61 lupin 2
62 OsandBucs 2
63 Y Not 2
64 claudecat 1
65 CM8 1
66 Fallclassic66 1
67 freight69 1
68 ghostofErikThompson 1
69 Gromm 1
70 OEutaw 1
71 Orangerunner 1
72 OsNBohs 1
73 PatrioticMerkin 1
74 Poseur 1
75 selftitled85 1
76 Sierra Matt 1
77 Son of Roenickstein 1
78 WhyaTerp 1
79 zsiv 1

Most Rec'd Comments (min 3)

# Recs Commenter Comment Link
25 Southern Marylander [no title]
23 PonsonPwn This post was so premature I thought it was WW
13 Southern Marylander [no title]
13 Pocket Ninja X
11 hnmnf Best move of the off-season by far
11 Jakubazookas [no title]
11 risuena No pictures yet
10 SibiGnana First time I tried to do a gif but I kind of failed
10 risuena More important than spring training today
9 aaronroyer Nice first gif
9 Southern Marylander [no title]
9 Eat More Esskay [no title]
9 PhilR8 SoMder got lost on the way to a fanpost
9 NickMarkaces Happy birthday ED-DIE!
8 daveh873 [no title]
8 wbecke01 Eddie's my all time fave ...
8 daveh873 Ahahahaha
8 Southern Marylander [no title]
8 aaronroyer [no title]
7 Tunaflipper Alright, I'll bite.
7 Pocket Ninja Okay last one
7 Quisenberry4Ever hunny bunny can you hand Eddie his HOF plaque.
6 PBR me ASAP! sorry
6 PonsonPwn Facial hair hall of famer
6 WestcoastO'sFan Sorry it isn't sexy Ben Zobrist.
6 Jakubazookas CRUZ CTRL
5 Quisenberry4Ever weather.com says temps in the 20-30s with off and on rain and snow have returned for the next 10-14 days.....
5 Jakubazookas I love this. You got one dog lookin' this way. The other dog lookin' that way. And then you got this guy over here and he's like, "Whaddya want from me?"
5 the madman of birdland You should write a one page paper for EME about Josh Hart
5 Southern Marylander [no title]
5 Southern Marylander The Jimenez Theorem - Hypothesis On The Likelihood of Ubaldo Jimenez Exceeding Bronson Arroyo's Performance In Upcoming Seasons
5 Jokes & Burns I finally bought a car. Just under 4 weeks since my accident
5 Jakubazookas You're the guy two rows back in the Rays jersey
5 zknower Hello Chatters
5 Osinnyc They are from Staten Island
5 Astronaut Mike Dexter I'll rec this for Obama's comments on Harold Ramis
5 WestcoastO'sFan Magnet schools, how do they work?
5 Philly O's I forgot the game but it was either the 1996 or 1997 season
5 Wieters Wieners [no title]
5 Astronaut Mike Dexter [no title]
4 D.Szymborski [no title]
4 Joe Davola Is this really a thing?
4 Southern Marylander [no title]
4 O'sFan21 and yet
4 Philly O's um, yes...
4 James F FWIW
4 D.Szymborski [no title]
4 Eat More Esskay It's almost like you don't need as big of a military if you don't invade two Middle East countries in the span of 18 months
4 PBR me ASAP! hey, if you don't like the NFL's policies you are free to not watch their product or purchase anything they offer
4 Southern Marylander [no title]
4 risuena Well, I'm already an aunt
4 Jokes & Burns Not like you'd see anything in the .gif anyway
4 Eat More Esskay Where in the first amendment does it talk about the NFL?
4 NSOsFan They're too sickly to type.
4 NSOsFan Meat is fucking delicious. Especially slow cooked and barbecued meats.
4 Pocket Ninja X
4 DaveAA A couple of months from now at this time of day...
3 Eat More Esskay We all better get used to the shells
3 James F Homophobia, primarily
3 Jake Nazar No more combined broadcasts?
3 Eat More Esskay The humor of Buck Showalter
3 Southern Marylander [no title]
3 daveh873 18 more years
3 kba26 So the second and probably final interview for that new job seemed to go pretty well yesterday
3 Darren89 Hey, you got your science in my baseball!
3 Stacey yes, let's make that post that gets hardly any traffic even more time consuming for me.
3 daveh873 #8
3 gio2chat Mornin... ...the Orioles are going to win it!
3 McNulty'sBirds Oh, Joe Angel, you sound so HOT
3 PBR me ASAP! ease up on the mescaline
3 kba26 [no title]
3 brek Nope.
3 daveh873 It's kinda weird that you call him "buddy" after a comment like that
3 Mark E. well, that shift key can really tweak a pinky if you arent careful
3 Southern Marylander [no title]
3 PBR me ASAP! per Brett Hollender
3 wbecke01 Eddie's birthday tomorrow
3 JeCaThRe [no title]
3 Strat12 [no title]
3 risuena FWIW
3 PTcello What is a "rec"
3 Wieters Wieners Someone on my Facebook had a baby on Tuesday!!!
3 Jakubazookas Most porn sex scenes are done when you are
3 JeCaThRe Shh, it'll be okay.
3 Philly O's LJ
3 kba26 How is that not exactly what's happening?

Recs Per Comment

Our leader this week is guest commenter Pocket Ninja who provided us with some sweet GIFs of new Oriole Nelson Cruz.

# Commenter # Recs # Comments Recs Per Comment
1 Pocket Ninja 24 3 8.00
2 D.Szymborski 8 2 4.00
3 aaronroyer 17 5 3.4
4 hnmnf 11 5 2.20
5 Jokes & Burns 9 5 1.80
6 Southern Marylander 93 61 1.52
7 Jake Nazar 3 2 1.50
8 PonsonPwn 31 27 1.15
9 eglooney 2 2 1.00
10 ghostofErikThompson 1 1 1.00
11 Gromm 1 1 1.00
12 Poseur 1 1 1.00
13 SibiGnana 10 10 1.00
14 wbecke01 14 14 1.00
15 WhyaTerp 1 1 1.00
16 gio2chat 8 10 0.80
17 Philly O's 12 15 0.80
18 NickMarkaces 9 12 0.75
19 Y Not 2 3 0.67
20 Darren89 3 6 0.50
21 zknower 7 15 0.47
22 PTcello 3 7 0.43
23 Quisenberry4Ever 25 62 0.40
24 daveh873 30 79 0.38
25 PBR me ASAP! 27 79 0.34
26 freight69 1 3 0.33
27 Osinnyc 5 16 0.31
28 McNulty'sBirds 4 13 0.31
29 Mark E. 4 14 0.29
30 risuena 31 113 0.27
31 Fallclassic66 1 4 0.25
32 OsandBucs 2 8 0.25
33 Son of Roenickstein 1 4 0.25
34 Astronaut Mike Dexter 17 72 0.24
35 James F 18 81 0.22
36 OEutaw 1 5 0.20
37 Orangerunner 1 5 0.20
38 selftitled85 1 5 0.20
39 brek 8 44 0.18
40 Stacey 11 62 0.18
41 pabirdfan 4 24 0.17
42 Eat More Esskay 39 237 0.16
43 Strat12 11 73 0.15
44 Jakubazookas 46 311 0.15
45 WestcoastO'sFan 17 115 0.15
46 Xari0tis 5 34 0.15
47 NSOsFan 12 84 0.14
48 Joe Davola 9 66 0.14
49 tflach2 3 22 0.14
50 Wieters Wieners 36 268 0.13
51 JeCaThRe 24 192 0.13
52 CStoneNo37 2 17 0.12
53 dfa 3 26 0.12
54 Andrew_Lew 11 96 0.11
55 PhilR8 13 117 0.11
56 DaveAA 6 58 0.10
57 kba26 18 183 0.10
58 lupin 2 21 0.10
59 Jakattak88 3 34 0.09
60 j.q. higgins 7 87 0.08
61 the madman of birdland 9 123 0.07
62 Emperor Lrrr 3 43 0.07
63 punkrawka 14 201 0.07
64 Sierra Matt 1 15 0.07
65 Tunaflipper 14 218 0.06
66 CM8 1 16 0.06
67 Zeke McGeek 3 49 0.06
68 zsiv 1 19 0.05
69 O'sFan21 18 354 0.05
70 duck 5 100 0.05
71 keyshonn 2 40 0.05
72 Broktun 4 82 0.05
73 claudecat 1 26 0.04
74 birdman 8 218 0.04
75 PatrioticMerkin 1 32 0.03
76 Andrew_G 2 66 0.03
77 fat_daddyo 7 238 0.03
78 OsNBohs 1 37 0.03
79 sluggo 2.0 3 131 0.02

Year to Date

Full results can be found here.

Top 25 Commenters

Jakubazookas becomes the first member of the 2K comment club.

# Commenter # Comments
1 Jakubazookas 2108
2 O'sFan21 1801
3 duck 1417
4 kba26 1370
5 Wieters Wieners 1368
6 WestcoastO'sFan 1325
7 Eat More Esskay 1195
8 birdman 1127
9 punkrawka 1061
10 PBR me ASAP! 978
11 Joe Davola 958
12 j.q. higgins 951
13 PhilR8 920
14 the madman of birdland 906
15 sluggo 2.0 849
16 Astronaut Mike Dexter 844
17 Andrew_Lew 826
18 Tunaflipper 712
19 daveh873 699
20 Broktun 683
21 PatrioticMerkin 663
22 Stacey 566
23 Strat12 566
24 NSOsFan 561
25 JeCaThRe 510

Most Recs - Top 25

Marylander has finally taken his rightful place atop this list.

# Commenter # Recs
1 Southern Marylander 331
2 Wieters Wieners 303
3 Jakubazookas 280
4 Stacey 225
5 Eat More Esskay 220
6 PBR me ASAP! 199
7 daveh873 193
8 kba26 166
9 PonsonPwn 147
10 O'sFan21 146
11 j.q. higgins 130
12 duck 124
13 NSOsFan 124
14 Joe Davola 117
15 punkrawka 107
16 Andrew_Lew 101
17 JeCaThRe 98
18 Quisenberry4Ever 98
19 James F 95
20 the madman of birdland 94
21 Astronaut Mike Dexter 91
22 WestcoastO'sFan 90
23 tflach2 89
24 DaveAA 78
25 CStoneNo37 75
25 PhilR8 75

Top 25 Recs Per Comment (minimum 80 comments)

MD'er just snuck in with 81 comments. He'll have to keep it up to stay on the leaderboard, though.

# Commenter # Recs # Comments Recs Per Comment
1 Southern Marylander 331 81 4.09
2 Quisenberry4Ever 98 155 0.63
3 Philly O's 41 87 0.47
4 PonsonPwn 147 326 0.45
5 Stacey 225 566 0.40
6 J(O's)elskIL 56 148 0.38
7 wbecke01 34 96 0.35
8 hnmnf 28 82 0.34
9 tflach2 89 267 0.33
10 zknower 60 187 0.32
11 daveh873 193 699 0.28
12 timg56 20 83 0.24
13 Wieters Wieners 303 1368 0.22
14 NSOsFan 124 561 0.22
15 risuena 67 305 0.22
16 PBR me ASAP! 199 978 0.20
17 DaveAA 78 395 0.20
18 JeCaThRe 98 510 0.19
19 James F 95 509 0.19
20 Eat More Esskay 220 1195 0.18
21 Chanumas 20 114 0.18
22 CStoneNo37 75 434 0.17
23 Zeke McGeek 33 211 0.16
24 brek 44 306 0.14
25 Emperor Lrrr 23 164 0.14
26 Xari0tis 14 102 0.14
27 j.q. higgins 130 951 0.14
28 Jakubazookas 280 2108 0.13
29 Jakattak88 16 123 0.13
30 Andrew_Lew 101 826 0.12
31 Joe Davola 117 958 0.12
32 kba26 166 1370 0.12
33 Strat12 67 566 0.12
34 Astronaut Mike Dexter 91 844 0.11
35 Andrew_G 16 150 0.11
36 the madman of birdland 94 906 0.10
37 CM8 9 88 0.10
38 punkrawka 107 1061 0.10
39 PatrioticMerkin 64 663 0.10
40 Jokes & Burns 27 300 0.09
41 duck 124 1417 0.09
42 PhilR8 75 920 0.08
43 O'sFan21 146 1801 0.08
44 dfa 12 159 0.08
45 perpetualstudent 7 101 0.07
46 WestcoastO'sFan 90 1325 0.07
47 birdman 70 1127 0.06
48 sluggo 2.0 50 849 0.06
49 pabirdfan 7 119 0.06
50 Tunaflipper 39 712 0.05
51 Broktun 37 683 0.05
52 keyshonn 8 203 0.04
53 Sierra Matt 6 154 0.04
54 fat_daddyo 14 504 0.03

Most Rec'd Comments

# # Recs Commenter Comment Link
1 31 j.q. higgins nice
2 30 Quisenberry4Ever Off topic: my daughter was born yesterday!!
3 29 Stacey Good news, friends
4 26 Southern Marylander [no title]
5 25 Southern Marylander [no title]
6 23 Southern Marylander Thoughts for Spring Training...
7 23 PonsonPwn This post was so premature I thought it was WW
8 20 Southern Marylander [no title]
9 20 Southern Marylander [no title]
10 18 Southern Marylander I'm ready to throw down.
11 17 J(O's)elskIL It's not even close. Cal>>>>>Jeter
12 16 PBR me ASAP! [no title]
13 16 punkrawka So kinda like NL baseball?
14 16 Stacey You know what?
15 16 CStoneNo37 Those are both significantly less than the 116 I am projecting.
16 16 tflach2 He didn't comment on Balfour's shoulder,
17 15 Southern Marylander The following post is payment to JeCaThRe for services provided and is in list format (as requested) with Jennifer Lawrence offering dramatic interpretations of my response to JeCaThRe offering said services.
18 15 aaronroyer Making a few offseason House of Cards gifs
19 14 aaronroyer ...
20 14 j.q. higgins [no title]
21 13 J(O's)elskIL I also wake up at 5am nearly every morning, no matter what
22 13 PonsonPwn Because all we need are Orioles gifs
23 13 O'sFan21 losing to the Yankees in the playoffs because of a blown call is a GREAT story
24 13 duck So, apparently, I just accidently deleted my school's entire website
25 13 Quisenberry4Ever thanks to everyone for the well wishes and congrats.
26 13 Southern Marylander [no title]
27 13 Pocket Ninja X

More From Camden Chat