clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Weekly comments and recs report: March 2-8

All the tables you can stomach

By Stacey
J. Meric
Roll Call Info, March 2-8
Total comments 4,390
Total commenters 149

Total Comments (>3)

We have a new leader!

# Commenter # Comments
1 fat_daddyo 405
2 O'sFan21 311
3 Jakubazookas 279
4 birdman 192
5 Tunaflipper 190
6 the madman of birdland 190
7 duck 175
8 kba26 158
9 Eat More Esskay 147
10 PBR me ASAP! 129
11 sluggo 2.0 111
12 punkrawka 106
13 Stacey 91
14 Broktun 91
15 Wieters Wieners 87
16 PhilR8 78
17 Strat12 78
18 j.q. higgins 74
19 James F 74
20 WestcoastO'sFan 73
21 DaveAA 61
22 Astronaut Mike Dexter 52
23 J(O's)elskIL 50
24 CStoneNo37 45
25 Orangerunner 41
26 nattybroh 40
27 risuena 40
28 CM8 39
29 fishoutawata 39
30 Joe Davola 39
31 JeCaThRe 38
32 Sierra Matt 35
33 hnmnf 34
34 NSOsFan 33
35 claudecat 31
36 Zeke McGeek 30
37 PonsonPwn 30
38 howski 26
39 keyshonn 26
40 Osinnyc 24
41 Emperor Lrrr 23
42 PatrioticMerkin 23
43 Darren89 22
44 Xari0tis 22
45 brek 22
46 pabirdfan 20
47 Michimore Wizskins 20
48 PaulFolk 20
49 Gilesj2 18
50 33 18
51 Jakattak88 18
52 gio2chat 16
53 Jokes & Burns 16
54 OEutaw 15
55 Andrew_Lew 14
56 Quisenberry4Ever 13
57 dippinkind 11
58 dfa 11
59 Philly O's 10
60 tjk 10
61 thewaywardO 10
62 Fahrenheit 451 10
63 lupin 9
64 perpetualstudent 8
65 tflach2 7
66 PTcello 7
67 wbecke01 6
68 droford 6
69 OsNBohs 6
70 OsandBucs 6
71 SibiGnana 6
72 Ryan Romano 6
73 OriolesRule13 6
74 alexw 6
75 McNulty'sBirds 5
76 Andrew Lind 5
77 Steve. 5
78 Russellgood2573 5
79 hookstrapped 4
80 OrioleGuru 4
81 Mark E. 4
82 Fallclassic66 4
83 Gamecock24 4
84 YeahDonnie 4
85 waitforthecall 4
86 freight69 4
87 AndrewTorrez 4
88 BENNY BIRDMAN 4
89 maddi 4
90 Bill in LA 4

Total Recs

Another new leader!

Commenter # Recs
punkrawka 35
Jakubazookas 28
Eat More Esskay 26
PBR me ASAP! 26
Joe Davola 17
Zeke McGeek 17
Broktun 16
the madman of birdland 16
kba26 15
James F 13
Wieters Wieners 13
duck 12
PonsonPwn 12
Quisenberry4Ever 12
Stacey 12
JeCaThRe 10
NSOsFan 10
Strat12 10
sluggo 2.0 9
birdman 8
claudecat 7
O'sFan21 7
Philly O's 7
PatrioticMerkin 6
Emperor Lrrr 5
fat_daddyo 5
j.q. higgins 5
Tunaflipper 5
Andrew_G 4
fishoutawata 4
PaulFolk 4
PhilR8 4
aaronroyer 3
BirdFanInPhilly 3
CM8 3
DaveAA 3
gio2chat 3
J(O's)elskIL 3
Orangerunner 3
thewaywardO 3
Astronaut Mike Dexter 2
booth not boo 2
brek 2
dippinkind 2
Jokes & Burns 2
NickMarkaces 2
OEutaw 2
Sierra Matt 2
WestcoastO'sFan 2
Andrew Lind 1
Andrew_Lew 1
angry_slav 1
Chanumas 1
CStoneNo37 1
Fahrenheit 451 1
hnmnf 1
hookstrapped 1
Jakattak88 1
Jake Nazar 1
jim66 1
Maffro 1
nattybroh 1
Osinnyc 1
PTcello 1
risuena 1
tflach2 1
tjk 1
UIWWildthing 1

Most Rec'd Comments (>2)

# Recs Commenter Comment Link
14 punkrawka [no title]
8 Quisenberry4Ever baseball gif of the day
8 James F Our?
6 Philly O's Day 2 Networkcolypse: Only the strong survive.
6 Joe Davola for your consideration
6 Eat More Esskay I'm not saying this is a Victory GIF Party
6 Zeke McGeek Help us Jonathan.
6 PBR me ASAP! [no title]
6 Eat More Esskay The wit and wisdom of Adam Jones
5 kba26 I propose changing the minimum number of comments to Marylander's total +1
5 Broktun He just told him a joke.
5 punkrawka If this doesn't make you laugh, you have no soul
5 Emperor Lrrr Pre-game view from my seat.
4 punkrawka You're just mad about my "Davola sux" bumper sticker
4 PonsonPwn Give that fan a contract!
4 Quisenberry4Ever Mets asked for Bundy,
4 NSOsFan ...
4 PBR me ASAP! Dude belongs in the Hall of Fame, imo.
4 Stacey Man, the Red Sox are awful :)
4 Eat More Esskay My opinion on pitch framing is get better umpires
4 James F What do lambs do on a farm besides eat, grow, and eventually become food and sweaters?
4 Joe Davola [no title]
4 PonsonPwn [no title]
4 Zeke McGeek That's pretty good. I like this one too:
4 Wieters Wieners (compliments of So. MDer)
3 Eat More Esskay Forget Drew, man. I'm riding the Flaherty bandwagon.
3 Broktun Lawn darts for giants?
3 PonsonPwn To be fair...
3 kba26 its a gateway legislation
3 aaronroyer From the Untweeted Archives
3 Andrew_G thats the only thing I've ever felt like spending money on
3 BirdFanInPhilly How many K's has Edwin tossed?
3 the madman of birdland yeah, plus, I stated that the yankees suck, so I'm pretty sure that is some sound reasoning
3 thewaywardO It be freak nicety up in this Ed Smith piece today
3 fishoutawata Or, for a visual:
3 JeCaThRe St. Peter don't you ask me, 'cause I can't go . . .
3 punkrawka [no title]
3 Stacey A few guys on Twitter were talking about how Chen isn't a good pitcher
3 PhilR8 Jim Hunter needs to take control of his life
3 PatrioticMerkin [no title]
3 duck The only bet I would make on UMd MBB this year
3 punkrawka And if OF21 tells you this, you need to take it to heart.
3 sluggo 2.0 I call them "Klingon" & "Ferengi" Republicans
3 PBR me ASAP! heh
3 J(O's)elskIL [no title]

Recs Per Comment

Commenter # Recs # Comments Recs Per Comment
BirdFanInPhilly 3 1 3.00
booth not boo 2 1 2.00
aaronroyer 3 2 1.5
Andrew_G 4 3 1.33
Jake Nazar 1 1 1.00
jim66 1 1 1.00
Maffro 1 1 1.00
UIWWildthing 1 1 1.00
Quisenberry4Ever 12 13 0.92
Philly O's 7 10 0.70
NickMarkaces 2 3 0.67
Zeke McGeek 17 30 0.57
angry_slav 1 2 0.50
Joe Davola 17 39 0.44
PonsonPwn 12 30 0.40
Chanumas 1 3 0.33
punkrawka 35 106 0.33
NSOsFan 10 33 0.30
thewaywardO 3 10 0.30
JeCaThRe 10 38 0.26
PatrioticMerkin 6 23 0.26
hookstrapped 1 4 0.25
claudecat 7 31 0.23
Emperor Lrrr 5 23 0.22
PBR me ASAP! 26 129 0.20
Andrew Lind 1 5 0.20
PaulFolk 4 20 0.20
gio2chat 3 16 0.19
dippinkind 2 11 0.18
Eat More Esskay 26 147 0.18
Broktun 16 91 0.18
James F 13 74 0.18
Wieters Wieners 13 87 0.15
PTcello 1 7 0.14
tflach2 1 7 0.14
OEutaw 2 15 0.13
Stacey 12 91 0.13
Strat12 10 78 0.13
Jokes & Burns 2 16 0.13
fishoutawata 4 39 0.10
Jakubazookas 28 279 0.10
Fahrenheit 451 1 10 0.10
tjk 1 10 0.10
kba26 15 158 0.09
brek 2 22 0.09
the madman of birdland 16 190 0.08
sluggo 2.0 9 111 0.08
CM8 3 39 0.08
Orangerunner 3 41 0.07
Andrew_Lew 1 14 0.07
duck 12 175 0.07
j.q. higgins 5 74 0.07
J(O's)elskIL 3 50 0.06
Sierra Matt 2 35 0.06
Jakattak88 1 18 0.06
PhilR8 4 78 0.05
DaveAA 3 61 0.05
birdman 8 192 0.04
Osinnyc 1 24 0.04
Astronaut Mike Dexter 2 52 0.04
hnmnf 1 34 0.03
WestcoastO'sFan 2 73 0.03
Tunaflipper 5 190 0.03
nattybroh 1 40 0.03
risuena 1 40 0.03
O'sFan21 7 311 0.02
CStoneNo37 1 45 0.02
fat_daddyo 5 405 0.01

Year To Date

Complete stats can be found here.

Top 25 Commenters

# Commenter # Comments
1 Jakubazookas 2387
2 O'sFan21 2112
3 duck 1592
4 kba26 1528
5 Wieters Wieners 1455
6 WestcoastO'sFan 1398
7 Eat More Esskay 1342
8 birdman 1319
9 punkrawka 1167
10 PBR me ASAP! 1107
11 the madman of birdland 1096
12 j.q. higgins 1025
13 PhilR8 998
14 Joe Davola 997
15 sluggo 2.0 960
16 fat_daddyo 909
17 Tunaflipper 902
18 Astronaut Mike Dexter 896
19 Andrew_Lew 840
20 Broktun 774
21 daveh873 699
22 PatrioticMerkin 686
23 Stacey 657
24 Strat12 644
25 NSOsFan 594

Most Recs - Top 25

# Commenter # Recs
1 Southern Marylander 331
2 Wieters Wieners 326
3 Jakubazookas 308
4 Eat More Esskay 246
5 Stacey 237
6 PBR me ASAP! 225
7 daveh873 193
8 kba26 181
9 PonsonPwn 159
10 O'sFan21 153
11 punkrawka 142
12 duck 136
13 j.q. higgins 135
14 Joe Davola 134
15 NSOsFan 134
16 Quisenberry4Ever 110
17 the madman of birdland 110
18 James F 108
19 JeCaThRe 108
20 Andrew_Lew 102
21 Astronaut Mike Dexter 93
22 WestcoastO'sFan 92
23 tflach2 90
24 DaveAA 81
25 PhilR8 79

Top 25 Recs Per Comment (minimum 90 comments)

# Commenter # Recs # Comments Recs Per Comment
1 Quisenberry4Ever 110 168 0.65
2 Philly O's 48 97 0.49
3 PonsonPwn 159 356 0.45
4 Stacey 237 657 0.36
5 wbecke01 34 96 0.35
6 tflach2 90 274 0.33
7 zknower 60 187 0.32
8 J(O's)elskIL 59 198 0.30
9 daveh873 193 699 0.28
10 hnmnf 29 116 0.25
11 NSOsFan 134 594 0.23
12 Wieters Wieners 326 1455 0.22
13 Zeke McGeek 50 241 0.21
14 PBR me ASAP! 225 1107 0.20
15 risuena 68 345 0.20
16 JeCaThRe 108 548 0.20
17 Osinnyc 18 92 0.20
18 James F 108 583 0.19
19 Eat More Esskay 246 1342 0.18
20 Chanumas 21 117 0.18
21 DaveAA 81 456 0.18
22 CStoneNo37 76 479 0.16
23 Emperor Lrrr 28 187 0.15
24 brek 46 328 0.14
25 Xari0tis 14 102 0.14
26 Joe Davola 134 997 0.13
27 j.q. higgins 135 1025 0.13
28 Andrew_G 20 153 0.13
29 Jakubazookas 308 2387 0.13
30 punkrawka 142 1167 0.12
31 Andrew_Lew 102 840 0.12
32 Jakattak88 17 141 0.12
33 Strat12 77 644 0.12
34 kba26 181 1528 0.12
35 nattybroh 12 106 0.11
36 Astronaut Mike Dexter 93 896 0.10
37 PatrioticMerkin 70 686 0.10
38 the madman of birdland 110 1096 0.10
39 CM8 12 127 0.09
40 Jokes & Burns 29 316 0.09
41 duck 136 1592 0.09
42 PhilR8 79 998 0.08
43 dfa 12 159 0.08
44 O'sFan21 153 2112 0.07
45 perpetualstudent 7 101 0.07
46 Broktun 53 774 0.07
47 WestcoastO'sFan 92 1398 0.07
48 sluggo 2.0 59 960 0.06
49 birdman 78 1319 0.06
50 pabirdfan 7 119 0.06
51 Tunaflipper 44 902 0.05
52 Sierra Matt 8 189 0.04
53 keyshonn 8 203 0.04
54 fat_daddyo 19 909 0.02

Most Rec'd Comments

# # Recs Commenter Comment Link
1 31 j.q. higgins nice
2 30 Quisenberry4Ever Off topic: my daughter was born yesterday!!
3 29 Stacey Good news, friends
4 26 Southern Marylander [no title]
5 25 Southern Marylander [no title]
6 23 Southern Marylander Thoughts for Spring Training...
7 23 PonsonPwn This post was so premature I thought it was WW
8 20 Southern Marylander [no title]
9 20 Southern Marylander [no title]
10 18 Southern Marylander I'm ready to throw down.
11 17 J(O's)elskIL It's not even close. Cal>>>>>Jeter
12 16 PBR me ASAP! [no title]
13 16 punkrawka So kinda like NL baseball?
14 16 Stacey You know what?
15 16 CStoneNo37 Those are both significantly less than the 116 I am projecting.
16 16 tflach2 He didn't comment on Balfour's shoulder,
17 15 Southern Marylander The following post is payment to JeCaThRe for services provided and is in list format (as requested) with Jennifer Lawrence offering dramatic interpretations of my response to JeCaThRe offering said services.
18 15 aaronroyer Making a few offseason House of Cards gifs
19 14 aaronroyer ...
20 14 j.q. higgins [no title]
21 14 punkrawka [no title]
22 13 J(O's)elskIL I also wake up at 5am nearly every morning, no matter what
23 13 PonsonPwn Because all we need are Orioles gifs
24 13 O'sFan21 losing to the Yankees in the playoffs because of a blown call is a GREAT story
25 13 duck So, apparently, I just accidently deleted my school's entire website
26 13 Quisenberry4Ever thanks to everyone for the well wishes and congrats.
27 13 Southern Marylander [no title]
28 13 Pocket Ninja X

More From Camden Chat