This 2010 ranking is a composite of the original 2006 list by Scott and my additions based on player performance since then.
40. Roberto Alomar
39. Harold Baines
38. Mike Boddicker
37. B.J. Surhoff
36. Nick Markakis
35. Tippy Martinez
34. Dick Hall
33. Rick Dempsey
32. Hoyt Wilhelm
31. Mike Flanagan
30. Steve Barber
29. Melvin Mora
28. Scott McGregor
27. Luis Aparacio
26. Brian Roberts
25. Don Buford
24. Chris Hoiles
23. Miguel Tejada
22. Jim Gentile
21. Davey Johnson
20. Mark Belanger
19. Stu Miller
18. Al Bumbry
17. Gus Triandos
16. Doug DeCinces
15. Paul Blair
14. Milt Pappas
13. Rafael Palmeiro
12. Bobby Grich
11. Mike Cuellar
10. Ken Singleton
9. Brady Anderson
8. Dave McNally
7. Mike Mussina
6. Boog Powell
5. Frank Robinson
4. Eddie Murray
3. Jim Palmer
2. Brooks Robinson
1. Cal Ripken